Makes ya wanna think.

Email to Dr. Norman Doidge

I was thrilled to get a comment from Dr. Norman Doidge on my blog post Bye-Bye Brainrot. Dr. Doidge wrote the book The Brain that Changes Itself, which was key to the recent reduction in my pain.

He asked me to drop him a line and this is what I wrote:

————————————–

Dr. Doidge,

Thanks much for stopping by my blog and commenting:

https://dougsharp.wordpress.com/2009/05/13/bye-bye-brainrot/

Your book has had a huge positive impact on my life. I am thrilled to be in touch with you.

Brainrot is my “affectionate” name for the epilepsy/pain condition which has disabled me periodically for 15 of my 57 years.

When brainrot first hit me I was 25 (1977). Then it was primarily an epilepsy condition centered in the left temporal lobe, but with a minor pain component. I’ve never had grand mal seizures; my epilepsy has been given a few different labels, including psychosomatic. Phenobarbital stabilized my first bout of brainrot and I was able to work as an elementary school teacher and then enter the computer game industry and write 2 hit games.

In 1988 brainrot knocked me out of commission again for 3 ½ years. Years spent searching for the right seizure med. The pain component was greater during this bout, usually before or during seizures. I was even evaluated for brain surgery in 91 just when my brain was stabilizing again. In 92 I dove back into computer games and in 93 got hired by Microsoft Research to code and manage in the Virtual Worlds Group.

After five fun, intense years at MSFT, in 97 brainrot struck again hard and I have been struggling with it for the past dozen years. From 98-2003 my seizures were out of control and the pain accompanying them became almost unbearable. The pain became horrid all the time, although seizures drove it through the roof. A wonderful neuropsychiatrist in Seattle, Dr. Vernon Neppe, worked with me for years to find the right meds to stabilize my seizures, which turned out to be Lamictal and Keppra. Dr. Neppe diagnosed me with Thalamic/Central Pain Syndrome. He thought that my seizures had damaged my thalamus so that most incoming nerve signals were labeled as pain.

My feet and lower legs were always at some level of pain – classic neuropathic symptoms. As my pain level gets higher I get flashes of pain down my left arm and then right arm. At its height my pain feels like a geyser of agony erupting through my skull – completely incapacitating.

I moved to my cabin in the Wisconsin woods in 2004 and living in this quiet, wild place has been tremendously healing. The general trend of my health has been upward, with a huge reduction in pain in the fall of 2005 which allowed me to do some programming and writing again. But my pain was constant and was amplified by activities such as intense conversations, doing even moderately complex operations involving lists and time, and listening to some rhythmic sounds.

Every few years I have searched out a new pain doctor for evaluation and treatment. Two years ago I went through a battery of tests at Marshfield Clinic and the U of Mn but the only relief they could offer was heavy painkillers that I didn’t want to take. Last summer I started seeing a counselor who recommended local pain specialist Dr. John Brendel.

I bought your book last fall after reading a great review in New Scientist. I am writing a sci-fi novel, Hel’s Bet ( http://helsbet.com ), that stars a woman who is into brain self-hackery, and The Brain that Changes Itself seemed like perfect fodder. As I read your book I thought about my own brain but couldn’t come up with any way of applying neuroplastic intervention to my brainrot.

On my first visit to Dr. Brendel he heard my history and said that he’d like to try something new. Was I familiar with the term neuroplasticity? I told him I’d read a book called The Brain that Changes Itself and Dr. Brendel was excited because he had just heard you talk at a pain conference. He told me that most of his patients just wanted pills to make the pain disappear.

His first suggested exercise was to find a smell that was comforting. I immediately knew my comfort smell was the scent of balsam fir needles. I was to smell that smell whenever my pain was at its peak. He encouraged me to experiment, to feel what actually worked and go with it.

I got no relief from the balsam pillow – it was soothing but the pain was still as pitiless as ever. I decided to try multisensory pleasure and started what I called my Sunset Healing practice (https://dougsharp.wordpress.com/2009/04/07/troubleshooting-my-brain/ ). I live in a cabin facing west on a lake and sunsets are wonderful. I took 20 minutes every sunset to pamper every sense – smell: the balsam pillow, hearing: a CD of soothing harp music, taste: fresh fruit, sight:  a beautiful sunset, and touch: the feel of my two dogs’ fur as I petted them.

I quickly discovered that only the sense of touch offered relief, so I concentrated on petting my dogs (which they love!) I petted them with my feet and it was immensely soothing, but the pain level overall didn’t budge.

I started to try different ways of petting the dogs with my feet and suddenly started to feel startling flickers of complete cessation of pain. I zeroed in on what I was doing when I felt those painfree flickers and quickly discovered that it didn’t matter whether my feet were feeling pleasurable sensations, it only mattered that they were feeling new sensations and that I was paying close attention to those sensations.

As I experimented, again and again I felt my pain flicker completely away. It wasn’t a gradual reduction of pain slowly dipping from 5 (on the subjective 0-10 pain scale) down through all the levels to 0 – it was an immediate flicker from a 5 to 0 to 5 again. I concentrated on refining my exercises, guided by the pain-free flicker.

What I discovered is that I needed to practice tasks that makes me concentrate on new sensations in my feet . The sensations didn’t have to be pleasant or soothing; they just had to be new. This made a lot of sense to me under the neuroplastic model. I could visualize new pathways being established and strengthened, routing around the damaged pathways in my thalamus.

The np model gives me a clear picture of what I’m doing when I “play footsy”: I am practicing feeling the real world.

So every day I do one or two ten-minute sessions with a box of objects that I manipulate with my feet – coins, marbles, a box of cards, string, paper, pens. I am training my feet to pick things up and manipulate them. In my quickest sessions I just dump the box and pick up every object with my toes and put them back in the box. In longer sessions I’ll put playing cards back in their box with my toes, write some words, balance things on the back of my foot, try to discover a pattern in the texture of the carpet.

Within a few weeks of starting these exercises my pain was entirely under control when I rested. I found that when I feel pain I don’t need a full 10-minute footsy session – I can feel around with my toes inside my shoe or take my shoes off and do a simple tactile task – following a seam with a toe, finding a toenail that needs cutting. I sometimes leave coins in my shoes to give my toes something to play with.

The neuroplastic model has also given me a new attitude toward my pain. I am so used to pain that it’s easy for me to ignore pain of level 3 or lower. When I’m in a little pain now I know that by ignoring it I am strengthening the painful, damaged neural pathways. That motivates me to do np exercises.

I had hoped for some reduction in my pain and was astounded that I often feel completely pain-free. I had given up hope of ever feeling relaxed and at ease in my body.

The transformation of my life has been profound. I can enjoy being around people (I am naturally sociable but my brainrot makes interaction painful). I enjoy exercise and take walks now to relax – 4 months ago I walked every day but was always exhausted and needed hours to recover. I am much more in touch with the world through all my senses because I don’t have to clench myself against constant pain.

As someone who loves science I know that I may be fooling myself about what’s going on. It’s hard to do a valid experiment with N=1. But I do have hope that my experience might point the way for effective neuroplastic pain management for people suffering from Central Pain Syndrome. The fact that mine was caused by seizures rather than a lesion might mean that only borderline cases could benefit.

I still have significant cognitive and pain challenges (https://dougsharp.wordpress.com/2009/06/05/next-challenges/ ) but I am certain that I will be able to find or create neuroplastic exercises to recover what I lost. One of the greatest things about the neuroplastic model is that I now feel responsible for my recovery. I am no longer waiting for a neurologist to find the right mix of meds to fix me. I developed my np pain exercises and I know I can develop exercises to rebuild my lost ability to deal with complexity.

Of course I would love to work with the best neuroplastic specialists to rebuild my lost cognitive skills. When I saw your comment on my blog I immediately thought – wow! I bet he can hook me up with the best people to work with. Any referrals would be wonderful.

Thanks again for your great book and your passion for spreading the word about our brains’ potential for change.

Gratefully,

Doug Sharp

————————————–

I’ll report back here when he replies.

About these ads

8 responses

  1. Victor Hornback

    Hey Cuz! I was wondering how you were doing and where you landed after Seattle. The Interwebs lead me to this quiet place in the woods.

    Sounds like a fascinating book (The Brain That Changes Itself). I will plan on reading it next!

    It’s great to hear that this has helped you with your pain. Can’t help but wonder if there might be something here for people with other sources of chronic pain.

    Anyway, I think it’s wonderful that you are back to writing and working on video games! (Nice blog too!)

    Warm Regards,
    Victor

    July 14, 2009 at 2:40 pm

    • Victor! Great hearing from you, cuz. Thanks for getting in touch. Email on the way! Doug

      July 14, 2009 at 3:34 pm

  2. Louise Mowder

    Dear Mr Sharp, It sounds as if you had classic Central Pain Syndrome, which has also been called Thalamic Pain Syndrome and Dejerine-Roussy Syndrome. While CPS has been recognized as an actual pain for a century, most sufferers- and I do mean sufferers – go undiagnosed and dismissed as hypochondriacs.

    This disease strikes after the CNS has been damaged in some way. It can be caused by stroke, MS, epilepsy, and spinal cord/brain injuries. It feels like Hell, literally. See http://www.painonline.org/ for more info.

    It is estimated that CPS is as common as Parkinson’s but remains undiagnosed in the majority of sufferers such as yourself. I myself am CPS patient, having had a stroke two years ago. I am a member of an online group of patients, and people join us every day., searching desperately for some relief from pain that has driven them to the brink of suicide.

    As you know, there can be no hyperbole when searching for terms to describe this suffering. I believe that advances in our knowledge of brain plasticity will provide a cure similar to that achieved for amputees in work of V.S. Ramachandran.

    I would really appreciate communicating with you about the development of your treatment plan. Is it possible for you to contact me at the above email address? You provide a ray of light in a pitch-black wave.

    Congratulations and blessings,

    Louise Mowder

    July 27, 2009 at 7:02 am

    • Wonderful to talk to you, Louise. I am hopeful that neuroplastic exercises can help Central Pain Syndrome sufferers. I look forward to working with you to spread the word.

      July 28, 2009 at 3:43 pm

  3. Chris

    Dear Doug,

    Congrats on all your hard earned progress! I too suffer from a debilitating brain pain and I’ve seen a number of medical professionals who — to date– are all at a loss to explain my symptoms. Last fall, Dr. Doidge’s book, The Brain That Changes Itself, was recommended to me by my physician and it has become an inspirational addition to my life. Recently, I have been searching for a means in which to reach out to Dr. Doidge. I’m curious to know if you would be willing to share his email address with me privately, so that I might attempt to contact him as you have successfully done? Doing so could prove to be extremely helpful to my cause and I would be eternally grateful.

    Wishing you continued good health,

    Chris

    July 29, 2009 at 8:46 am

  4. Clay Taylor

    Hi Doug,

    Victor Hornbeck is a friend of mine in Colorado Springs and he put me in touch with your website and the book by Dr. Doige. I have a 12 year history of severe pain, and wanted to send an emial to Dr. Doige after reading his book. Do you know how to contact him?

    Thank you,

    Clay Talor

    December 9, 2009 at 7:51 pm

    • Clay, I emailed Dr. Doidge after he left a comment on my blog – https://dougsharp.wordpress.com/2009/05/13/bye-bye-brainrot/#comments – but didn’t get a reply. I have been putting all my energy into finishing my novel, and now that I am done with it am going to try to get in touch with Dr. Doidge. I’ll post in my blog if I make contact. Best wishes on getting relief.

      December 10, 2009 at 7:22 pm

  5. I was curious if you ever thought of changing the structure of your site?
    Its very well written; I love what youve got to say.
    But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people
    could connect with it better. Youve got an awful
    lot of text for only having one or 2 images.
    Maybe you could space it out better?

    December 24, 2012 at 6:22 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 118 other followers